Economic Valuation of Hypothetical Paratransit Retrofitting

Naili Huda, Kim Peter Hassall, Sunarto - Kaleg, Abdul - Hapid


This paper describes a feasibility analysis of conventional and retrofitted paratransits, comparing economic performance of conventional paratransit with those using lead acid and lithium batteries. Research object is Dago-Kalapa paratransit in Bandung, West Java, travelling the distance of 11 km in town, under 8 peak hour operation. After calculating the estimated annual cost and benefit; net present value (NPV), payback period (PBP) and internal rate of return (IRR) then were quantified to provide feasibility description of those three paratransits. In addition, a sensitivity analysis regarding discount rate, gasoline price and battery price is given to offer broader sense of factors embraced. It is found that both gasoline and lead acid paratransit have big NPVs with only slight differences, while lithium paratransit has negative NPV. This phenomenon applies to their PBPs and IRRs as well. Only when gasoline costs reaches IDR 15,000 will electric paratransit prevails over conventional one. Thus, it can be inferred that at the moment, paratransit runs with gasoline is still the most cost effective compared to its counterparts. However, starting retrofitting from now is endorsed due to its environmental benefit.


feasibility; paratransit; conventional; electric; Bandung Indonesia

Full Text:



B. H. Pro, et al., "Energy and land use impacts of sustainable transportation scenarios," Journal of Cleaner Production, p. 11, 2005. crossref

I. Hossain, "Lifecycle analysis of different urban transport options for Bangladesh," Energy Policy, p. 10, Gurcan Gulen. crossref

M. Werber, et al., "Batteries: Lower cost than gasoline? ," Energy Policy, p. 4, 2009.crossref

H. Mousazadeh, et al., "Technical and economical assessment of a multipurpose electric vehicle for farmers," Journal of Cleaner Production, vol. 17, p. 7, 2009. crossref

M. A. Delucchi and T. E. Lipman, "An analysis of the retail and lifecycle cost of battery-powered electric vehicles," Transportation Research Part D, p. 34, 2001. crossref

G. J. Offer, et al., "Comparative analysis of battery electric, hydrogen fuel cell and hybrid vehicles in a future sustainable road transport system," Energy Policy, vol. 38, pp. 24-29, 2010. crossref

J. Van Mierlo, et al., "Which energy source for road transport in the future? A comparison of battery, hybrid and fuel cell vehicles," Energy Conversion and Management, vol. 47, pp. 2748-2760, 2006. crossref

Vutetakis, D. and Timmons, J., "A Comparison of Lithium-Ion and Lead-Acid Aircraft Batteries," SAE Technical Paper 2008-01-2875, 2008. crossref

B. Bednar, et al., "Diagnostic tool for lithium and lead-acid battery," in Clean Electrical Power (ICCEP), 2013 International Conference on, 2013, pp. 84-86. crossref

N. Omar, et al., "Rechargeable Energy Storage Systems for Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles--Assessment of Electrical Characteristics," Energies (19961073), vol. 5, pp. 2952-2988, 2012. crossref

J. McDowall, "Conventional battery technologies-present and future," in Power Engineering Society Summer Meeting, 2000. IEEE, 2000, pp. 1538-1540 vol. 3. crossref

M. Gustavsson and D. Mtonga, "Lead-acid battery capacity in solar home systems—Field tests and experiences in Lundazi, Zambia," Solar Energy, vol. 79, pp. 551-558, 2005. crossref

E. M. Krieger, et al., "A comparison of leadacid and lithium-based battery behavior and capacity fade in off-grid renewable charging applications," Energy, vol. 60, pp. 492-500, 2013. crossref

R. Spotnitz, "Simulation of capacity fade in lithium-ion batteries," Journal of Power Sources, vol. 113, pp. 72-80, 2003. crossref

J. Leadbetter and L. G. Swan, "Selection of battery technology to support grid-integrated renewable electricity," Journal of Power Sources, vol. 216, pp. 376-386, 2012. crossref

J. X. Weinert, et al., "Lead-acid and lithiumion batteries for the Chinese electric bike market and implications on future technology advancement," Journal of Power Sources, vol. 172, pp. 938-945, 2007. crossref

P. Cicconi, et al., "Cooling Simulation of an EV Battery Pack to Support a Retrofit Project from Lead-Acid to Li-Ion Cells," in Vehicle Power and Propulsion Conference (VPPC), 2013 IEEE, 2013, pp. 1-6. crossref

K. T. Chau, et al., "An overview of energy sources for electric vehicles," Energy Conversion and Management, vol. 40, pp. 1021-1039, 1999. crossref

S. J. Gerssen-Gondelach and A. P. C. Faaij, "Performance of batteries for electric vehicles on short and longer term," Journal of Power Sources, vol. 212, pp. 111-129, 2012. crossref

R. L. Lankey and F. C. McMichael, "Lifecycle methods for comparing primary and rechargeable batteries," Environment and Science Technology, p. 6, 2000. crossref

M. A. Kreusch, et al., "Technological improvements in automotive battery recycling," Resources, Conservation and Recycling, p. 13, 2007. crossref

I. B. Weinstock, "Recent advances in the US Department of Energy's energy storage technology research and development programs for hybrid electric and electric vehicles," Journal of Power Sources, vol. 110, p. 4, 2002. crossref

A. Vasebi, et al., "A novel combined battery model for state-of-charge estimation in leadacid batteries based on extended Kalman filter for hybrid electric vehicle applications," Journal of Power Sources, vol. 174, p. 41, 2007. crossref

D. M. Kammen, "Cost-effectiveness of greenhouse gas emission reductions from plug-in hybrid electric vehicles," Goldman School of Public Policy Working Paper No. GSPP08-014, 2008. crossref

R. Faria, et al., "A sustainability assessment of electric vehicles as a personal mobility system," Energy Conversion and Management, vol. 61, pp. 19-30, 2012. crossref

Article Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

Metrics powered by PLOS ALM


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2015 Journal of Mechatronics, Electrical Power, and Vehicular Technology

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.